Drive

See also: Avenue

History

Fig. 1, Miller & Co., Map of the residence & park grounds, near Bordentown, New Jersey: of the late Joseph Napoleon Bonaparte, ex-king of Spain [detail], 1847.

Fig. 2, Alexander Jackson Davis, Mount Vernon, c. 1831

Approaches, roads, avenues, and other circulation routes have always been an important component of American landscape design, but the term drive as a designation for a carriage road (as opposed to walks and paths for pedestrians and horseback riders) did not come into common usage in America until the second quarter of the 19th century. Even then it appears to have been used only by treatise writers. Although earlier sites, such as Monticello and Mount Vernon, included similar serpentine ways leading to the house, these routes usually were designated as avenues or roads.

Fig. 3, Anonymous, The Lilacs, Residence of Thomas Kidder [perspective rendering, front], c. 1810.

Fig. 4, Thomas S. Sinclair, Ashland, The Home of Henry Clay, 1852

A. J. Downing distinguished a drive from an approach, placing emphasis on the location of the roadways within an estate. In his lexicon, an approach, whether straight in the manner of the “ancient style” or serpentine following the “modern style,” led the traveler from the public road to the house. The drive, in contrast, began where the approach terminated and carried the visitor through the estate, as with the several miles of graveled drives that he praised at Beaverwyck, near Albany, or the circuitous drives of Anthony Bleeker’s 1847 plan for Point Breeze [Fig. 1] in Bordentown, New Jersey. Other treatise writers, such as James E. Teschemacher in 1835, used the term “drive” more broadly to include curvilinear drives to the house, those that Downing would have called “approaches.” The majority of descriptions of drives, with their sweeping curves (which allowed one to experience the changing scenery of the landscape), relate to the large estates of America’s wealthiest families. Only by the mid-19th century did the term’s meaning shift, when George Jaques in 1852 applied the term to circulation routes at residential dwellings of modest scale. As such, the meaning began to approximate the contemporary term driveway.

Fig. 5, John Notman, “Plan of Grounds, Fieldwood, near Princeton,” October 19, 1846.

As the term itself implies, a drive was part of the processional experience of the natural or picturesque landscape. It offered the carriage traveler varied scenery, views of distant prospects, and glimpses of the main house [Figs. 2–4]. Views of the house that became evident as one approached from an oblique angle, Downing noted, were beneficial for “displaying not only the beauty of the architectural façade but also one of the end elevations.” Thus, the views gave “a more complete idea of the size, character, or elegance of the building.” Where possible, these modern drives took advantage of the natural scenery, as in Downing's design for Montgomery Place on the Hudson, where he followed his own advice that a road “should never curve without some reason, either real or apparent [his italics].” The intricacy of the circulation routes and their incorporation of views are further exemplified in John Notman’s plan of 1846 for Woodlawn in Princeton, New Jersey [Fig. 5].

Fig. 6, John Caspar Wild, Laurel Hill Cemetery, Philadelphia, 1838.

The feature of the drive in public space offered a more affordable venue for pedestrians and horseback riders to enjoy the natural and artificially constructed beauty of the Schuylkill River and Fairmount Waterworks, Gray’s Ferry, and Laurel Hill Cemetery in Philadelphia [Fig. 6]. Downing's plan for Washington, DC, incorporated several miles of drives for carriages (as opposed to walks for pedestrians) to enable visitors to circulate through the national park. In this case, the drive was also a means to an end, allowing visitors to benefit from the didactic purposes of the “sylvan museum.”

The attention given in American landscape designs of the 1840s to circulation routes suitable for carriages in both public and residential space may partly reflect the technological innovations in vehicle suspension systems that had developed in England. These improvements and the simultaneous efforts to develop roadways allowed faster travel that, in turn, was instrumental in the growing practice of touring British country estates. While touring was not as highly developed in America, landscape designs often incorporated the same aesthetic principles of opening views and creating a varied experience for the visitor driving through the landscape. Downing cautioned that “the curves should never be so great, or lead over surfaces so unequal, as to make it disagreeable to drive upon them.”

—Elizabeth Kryder-Reid

---

Texts

Usage

• Downing, Andrew Jackson, October 1847, describing Montgomery Place, country home of Mrs. Edward (Louise) Livingston, Dutchess County, NY (quoted in Haley 1988: 45)

“On the south [natural boundary of the estate] is a rich oak wood, in the centre of which is a private drive.”

• Downing, Andrew Jackson, 1849, describing Montgomery Place, country home of Mrs. Edward (Louise) Livingston, Dutchess County, NY (1849; repr. 1991: 49)

“A large conservatory, an exotic garden, an arboretum, etc., are among the features of interest in this admirable residence. Including a drive through a fine bit of natural wood, south of the mansion, there are five miles of highly varied and picturesque private roads and walks, through the pleasure-grounds of Montgomery Place.”

Fig. 7, Anonymous, “Beaverwyck, the Seat of Wm. P. Van Rensselaer, Esq.,” in A. J. Downing, A Treatise on the Theory and Practice of Landscape Gardening (1849), pl. opp. 51, fig. 7.

• Downing, Andrew Jackson, 1849, describing Beaverwyck, the seat of William P. Van Rensselaer, near Albany, NY (1849; repr. 1991: 51)

“The whole estate is ten or twelve miles square. . . The home residence embraces several hundred acres, with a large level lawn, bordered by highly varied surface of hill and dale. . . The grounds are yet newly laid out, but with much judgement; and six or seven miles of winding gravelled roads and walks have been formed—their boundaries now leading over level meadows, and now winding through woody dells. The drives thus afforded, are almost unrivalled in extent and variety, and give the stranger or guest, an opportunity of seeing the near and distant views to the best advantage.” [Fig. 7]

Fig. 8, A. J. Downing, Plan Showing Proposed Method of Laying Out the Public Grounds at Washington, 1851. Manuscript copy by Nathaniel Michler, 1867.

• Downing, Andrew Jackson, December 1851, “The State and Prospects of Horticulture” (Horticulturist 6: 540–41)

“The plan [for a public ground in Washington] embraces four or five miles of carriage-drive—walks for pedestrians—ponds of water, fountains and statues—picturesque groupings of trees and shrubs, and a complete collection of all the trees that belong to North America. It will, if carried out as it has been undertaken, undoubtedly give a great impetus to the popular taste in landscape-gardening and the culture of ornamental trees; and as the climate of Washington is one peculiarly adapted to this purpose—this national park may be made a sylvan museum such as it would be difficult to equal in beauty and variety in any part of the world.” [Fig. 8]

Citations

• Loudon, J. C. (John Claudius), 1826, An Encyclopaedia of Gardening (1826: 1021)

“7267. The riding, or drive, is a road indicated rather than formed, which passes through the most interesting and distant parts of a residence not seen in detail from the walks, and as far into the adjoining lands of wildness or cultivation, as the property of the owner extends. It is also frequently conducted as much farther as the disposition of adjoining proprietors permits, or the general face of the country renders desirable.”

• Teschemacher, James E. (James Englebert), November 1, 1835, “On Horticultural Architecture” (Horticultural Register 1: 411)

“The approach to the house should be by a broad semi-circular drive intersecting the lawns, and leading by branches to the stables and out buildings, as well as to the flower and kitchen gardens; this last, if near the house, must be completely concealed, either by walls covered with fruit trees, or by shrubberies, and may be preferably laid out in a series of parallelograms.”

• Downing, Andrew Jackson, 1849, A Treatise on the Theory and Practice of Landscape Gardening (1849; repr., 1991: 337, 341–42)

“There are two guiding principles which have been laid down for the formation of Approach roads. The first, that the curves should never be so great, or lead over surfaces so unequal, as to make it disagreeable to drive upon them; and the second, that the road should never curve without some reason, either real or apparent.

“The Drive is a variety of road rarely seen among us, yet which may be made a very agreeable feature in some of our country residences, at a small expense. It is intended for exercise more secluded than that upon the public road, and to show the interesting portions of the place from the carriage, or on horseback. Of course it can only be formed upon places of considerable extent; but it enhances the enjoyment of such places very highly, in the estimation of those who are fond of equestrian exercises. It generally commences where the approach terminates, viz. near the house: and from thence, proceeds in the same easy curvilinear manner through various parts of the grounds, farm, or estate. Sometimes it sweeps through the pleasure grounds, and returns along the very beach of the river, beneath the fine over-hanging foliage of its projecting bank; sometimes it proceeds towards some favorite point of view, or interesting spot on the landscape; or at others it leaves the lawn and traverses the farm, giving the proprietor an opportunity to examine his crops, or exhibit his agricultural resources to his friends.”

• Jaques, George, January 1852, “Landscape Gardening in New-England” (Horticulturist 7: 35)

“A gracefully curved drive or walk, (from the public street to the buildings,) entering through an irregular group of trees, and forced into its curvature by another little group, will of itself impart to a rural home charms far more pleasing than ten times their cost could infuse into the stiff, old straight-lined primness of the ancient style.”

---

Images

Inscribed

• 

  J. C. Loudon, Plan of a ferme ornée with wild and irregular hedges, in An Encyclopædia of Gardening (1826), 1023, fig. 722. "Hedges. . . are bordered on each side by a board green drive. . .”

Associated

• 

  James E. Teschemacher, “The approach to the house should be by a broad semi-circular drive. . . ” in Horticultural Register, and Gardener’s Magazine 1 (May 1, 1835): opp. 157.

• 

  Anonymous, “Beaverwyck, the Seat of Wm. P. Van Rensselaer, Esq.,” in A. J. Downing, A Treatise on the Theory and Practice of Landscape Gardening (1849), pl. opp. 51, fig. 7.

• 

  A. J. Downing, Plan Showing Proposed Method of Laying Out the Public Grounds at Washington, 1851.

• 

  A. J. Downing, Plan Showing Proposed Method of Laying Out the Public Grounds at Washington, 1851. Manuscript copy by Nathaniel Michler, 1867.

Attributed

• 

  Andreas Anton Lawatsch, “Prospect of Bethabara,” Salem, NC, c. 1759. The drive is the tree-lined avenue.

• 

  John Nancarrow, "Plan of the Seat of John Penn jun’r: Esqr: in Blockley Township and County of Philadelphia", c. 1785. A drive runs from point "f" to point "b".

• 

  Charles Fraser, Mepkin, No. 1, May 1805.

• 

  Anonymous, The Lilacs, Residence of Thomas Kidder [perspective rendering, front], c. 1810.

• 

  Anonymous, The Vale, 1820–30.

• 

  Anne-Marguerite Hyde de Neuville, Washington City, 1821.

• 

  Alexander Jackson Davis, Residence of Dr. David Hosack, Hyde Park, New York, c. 1830.

• 

  Alexander Jackson Davis, Mount Vernon, c. 1831

• 

  W. H. Bartlett, “Washington from the President’s House,” in Nathaniel Parker Willis, American Scenery (1840), vol. 2, pl. 26.

• 

  John Caspar Wild, Laurel Hill Cemetery, Philadelphia, 1838. A drive leads to the entrance of the cemetery.

• 

  John Notman, “Plan of Grounds, Fieldwood, near Princeton,” October 19, 1846.

• 

  Miller & Co., Map of the residence & park grounds, near Bordentown, New Jersey: of the late Joseph Napoleon Bonaparte, ex-king of Spain, 1847.

• 

  Anonymous, “Kenwood, Residence of J. Rathbone, Esq. near Albany, N.Y.,” in A. J. Downing, A Treatise on the Theory and Practice of Landscape Gardening (1849), pl. opp. 50, fig. 9.

• 

  Anonymous, “Villa of Theodore Lyman, Esq., near Boston,” in A. J. Downing, A Treatise on the Theory and Practice of Landscape Gardening (1849), 387, fig. 48.

• 

  Orsamus Turner, Life Cycle of a Pioneer Woodsman (“Third Sketch of the Pioneer”), in Pioneer History of the Holland Purchase (1850), opp. 565.

• 

  Thomas S. Sinclair, Ashland, The Home of Henry Clay, 1852.

• 

  Edward Beyer, Blue Sulphur Spring, Greenbrier County, VA, 1857.

• 

  After Edward Beyer, Salt Sulphur Spring, 1857, 1857.

---