Talk:Porch - Revision history

R-Asleson: Blanked the page

2015-08-28T19:32:40Z

Blanked the page

R-Asleson at 16:41, July 28, 2015

2015-07-28T16:41:02Z

R-Asleson at 16:39, July 28, 2015

2015-07-28T16:39:32Z

R-Asleson at 14:10, July 28, 2015

2015-07-28T14:10:59Z

R-Asleson at 19:06, July 9, 2015

2015-07-09T19:06:03Z

K-perkov at 21:18, July 2, 2015

2015-07-02T21:18:16Z

C-tompkins at 16:07, July 2, 2015

2015-07-02T16:07:42Z

C-tompkins at 16:07, July 2, 2015

2015-07-02T16:07:26Z

C-tompkins at 16:07, July 2, 2015

2015-07-02T16:07:12Z

K-perkov at 20:16, June 25, 2015

2015-06-25T20:16:35Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:32, August 28, 2015
Line 1:		Line 1:
−	[KP 6/25/15] It is unclear to me if "Rustic Seat" (File: 0358) should be listed as an inscribed image for porch. The text accompanying the image describes many different architectural features, including a "a rustic seat, placed on a bold little plateau, at the base of a large tree, eighty feet above the water", a "little rustic pavilion, from which a much lower and wider view of the landscape is again enjoyed", and "a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic proch" [sic].
−	~~<br/> [CT 7/2/15] "Porch" is actually spelled correctly in ''Horticulturist''...it was just misspelled in FileMaker (fixed now). But I agree that it should be associated.~~
−

−	~~RA 7/9/15: See Veranda's Discussion page for problems in the second paragraph of the Porch page (as well as those for Portico and Piazza)~~
−
−	~~RA 7/9/15: I'm not sure that the Downing quotation about the rustic porch at Montgomery Place makes an argument about porches "directing a view or prospect." Here's the quotation:~~
−
−	::"Not long after leaving the rustic pavilion, on descending by one of the paths that diverges to the left, we reach a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic porch. The roof is prettily thatched with thick green moss. Nestling under a dark canopy of evergreens in the shelter of a rocky fern-covered bank, an hour or two may be whiled away within it, almost unconscious of the passage of time."

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 RA 7/9/15: See Veranda's Discussion page for problems in the second paragraph of the Porch page (as well as those for Portico and Piazza)
-RA 7/9/15: I'm not sure that the Downing quotation about the rustic porch at __ really makes an argument about porches framing views/prospects. Here's the quotation:
+RA 7/9/15: I'm not sure that the Downing quotation about the rustic porch at Montgomery Place makes an argument about porches "directing a view or prospect." Here's the quotation:
 ::"Not long after leaving the rustic pavilion, on descending by one of the paths that diverges to the left, we reach a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic porch. The roof is prettily thatched with thick green moss. Nestling under a dark canopy of evergreens in the shelter of a rocky fern-covered bank, an hour or two may be whiled away within it, almost unconscious of the passage of time."

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:39, July 28, 2015
Line 4:		Line 4:

	RA 7/9/15: See Veranda's Discussion page for problems in the second paragraph of the Porch page (as well as those for Portico and Piazza)		RA 7/9/15: See Veranda's Discussion page for problems in the second paragraph of the Porch page (as well as those for Portico and Piazza)
		+
		+	RA 7/9/15: I'm not sure that the Downing quotation about the rustic porch at __ really makes an argument about porches framing views/prospects. Here's the quotation:
		+
		+	::"Not long after leaving the rustic pavilion, on descending by one of the paths that diverges to the left, we reach a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic porch. The roof is prettily thatched with thick green moss. Nestling under a dark canopy of evergreens in the shelter of a rocky fern-covered bank, an hour or two may be whiled away within it, almost unconscious of the passage of time."

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:10, July 28, 2015
Line 3:		Line 3:


−	RA 7/9/15: ~~There is a missing text and/or citation~~ for ~~the sentence "Downing used the term "pavilion" synonymously with "veranda." I cannot find "pavilion" used~~ in the ~~sense~~ of ~~"veranda" in Downing's treatise. He seems to equate pavilions with detached garden structures, such~~ as ~~temples and rustic seats. Here is what he says: <p></p>~~	+	RA 7/9/15: See Veranda's Discussion page for problems in the second paragraph of the Porch page (as well as those for Portico and Piazza)
−	~~: "a prospect tower or rustic pavilion, on a little eminence overlooking the whole estate..."<p></p>~~
−	~~: "The temple and the pavilion are highly finished forms of covered seats"<p></p>~~
−	~~: "With regard to pavilions, summer-houses, rustic seats, and garden edifices of like character.... a classic temple or pavilion may crown a beautiful~~ and ~~prominent knoll, and a rustic covered seat may occupy a secluded, quiet portion of the grounds..."<p></p>~~
−	: "Large and costly hot-houses were erected by Dr. Hosack, with also entrance lodges at two points on the estate, a fine bridge over the stream, and numerous pavilions and seats commanding extensive prospects..."
−
−
−
−	~~[KP 7/2/15] In the third paragraph there is a quote from Rev. Manasseh Cutler describing Monticello without a citation.<p></p>~~
−	~~RA 7/9/15: I have looked through all the keyword term binders and done many Google searches without finding the source for the paraphrased Manasseh Cutler quote on Monticello.~~

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:06, July 9, 2015
Line 3:		Line 3:


−	[KP 7/2/15] In the third paragraph there is a quote from Rev. Manasseh Cutler describing Monticello without a citation.	+	RA 7/9/15: There is a missing text and/or citation for the sentence "Downing used the term "pavilion" synonymously with "veranda." I cannot find "pavilion" used in the sense of "veranda" in Downing's treatise. He seems to equate pavilions with detached garden structures, such as temples and rustic seats. Here is what he says: <p></p>
		+	: "a prospect tower or rustic pavilion, on a little eminence overlooking the whole estate..."<p></p>
		+	: "The temple and the pavilion are highly finished forms of covered seats"<p></p>
		+	: "With regard to pavilions, summer-houses, rustic seats, and garden edifices of like character.... a classic temple or pavilion may crown a beautiful and prominent knoll, and a rustic covered seat may occupy a secluded, quiet portion of the grounds..."<p></p>
		+	: "Large and costly hot-houses were erected by Dr. Hosack, with also entrance lodges at two points on the estate, a fine bridge over the stream, and numerous pavilions and seats commanding extensive prospects..."
		+
		+
		+
		+	[KP 7/2/15] In the third paragraph there is a quote from Rev. Manasseh Cutler describing Monticello without a citation.<p></p>
		+	RA 7/9/15: I have looked through all the keyword term binders and done many Google searches without finding the source for the paraphrased Manasseh Cutler quote on Monticello.

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:18, July 2, 2015
Line 1:		Line 1:
	[KP 6/25/15] It is unclear to me if "Rustic Seat" (File: 0358) should be listed as an inscribed image for porch. The text accompanying the image describes many different architectural features, including a "a rustic seat, placed on a bold little plateau, at the base of a large tree, eighty feet above the water", a "little rustic pavilion, from which a much lower and wider view of the landscape is again enjoyed", and "a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic proch" [sic].		[KP 6/25/15] It is unclear to me if "Rustic Seat" (File: 0358) should be listed as an inscribed image for porch. The text accompanying the image describes many different architectural features, including a "a rustic seat, placed on a bold little plateau, at the base of a large tree, eighty feet above the water", a "little rustic pavilion, from which a much lower and wider view of the landscape is again enjoyed", and "a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic proch" [sic].
	<br/> [CT 7/2/15] "Porch" is actually spelled correctly in ''Horticulturist''...it was just misspelled in FileMaker (fixed now). But I agree that it should be associated.		<br/> [CT 7/2/15] "Porch" is actually spelled correctly in ''Horticulturist''...it was just misspelled in FileMaker (fixed now). But I agree that it should be associated.
		+
		+
		+	[KP 7/2/15] In the third paragraph there is a quote from Rev. Manasseh Cutler describing Monticello without a citation.

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:07, July 2, 2015
Line 1:		Line 1:
	[KP 6/25/15] It is unclear to me if "Rustic Seat" (File: 0358) should be listed as an inscribed image for porch. The text accompanying the image describes many different architectural features, including a "a rustic seat, placed on a bold little plateau, at the base of a large tree, eighty feet above the water", a "little rustic pavilion, from which a much lower and wider view of the landscape is again enjoyed", and "a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic proch" [sic].		[KP 6/25/15] It is unclear to me if "Rustic Seat" (File: 0358) should be listed as an inscribed image for porch. The text accompanying the image describes many different architectural features, including a "a rustic seat, placed on a bold little plateau, at the base of a large tree, eighty feet above the water", a "little rustic pavilion, from which a much lower and wider view of the landscape is again enjoyed", and "a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic proch" [sic].
−	<br/> [CT 7/2/15] "Porch" is actually spelled correctly in ''Horticulturist''...it was just misspelled in FileMaker (fixed now). But I agree that it should be associated. ~~And the~~	+	<br/> [CT 7/2/15] "Porch" is actually spelled correctly in ''Horticulturist''...it was just misspelled in FileMaker (fixed now). But I agree that it should be associated.

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:16, June 25, 2015
Line 1:		Line 1:
−	[KP 6/22/15] ~~I've divided~~ "~~Piazza/Veranda/Porch/Portico~~" ~~into four separate pages~~. ~~As of now~~, ~~they have the same history essay with the exception that there are no double brackets around~~ the ~~word~~ of the ~~given page; for example~~, "~~Portico"~~ is ~~placed in double brackets on the~~ "~~veranda~~" ~~page~~, ~~but not on~~ the "~~portico" page~~.	+	[KP 6/25/15] It is unclear to me if "Rustic Seat" (File: 0358) should be listed as an inscribed image for porch. The text accompanying the image describes many different architectural features, including a "a rustic seat, placed on a bold little plateau, at the base of a large tree, eighty feet above the water", a "little rustic pavilion, from which a much lower and wider view of the landscape is again enjoyed", and "a charming little covered resting place, in the form of a rustic proch" [sic].